The Court decided that this case did not fall into that exception and hence the Court have jurisdiction. Proceedings have been instituted in respect of the offence in question or it is being investigated. I'd need to give that some further thought, and I note that the Court itself recognises that this is not a universally held position., The judges also criticised defence expert witnesses, saying: The experts have an important role in explaining how a system works, but no role whatever in construing an Act of Parliament. Were it the latter, the defence submitted that the material should as a result be excluded in terms of section 56 of the 2016 Act. The judgement will have major implications for cases against suspected organised criminals around the country. James Wright, 36, of Brewery Gardens, Gatecare was sentenced to 16 years for conspiracy to supply cocaine and diamorphine, conspiracy to supply cannabis and possessing criminal property. He was convicted of conspiracy to supply class A drugs and locked up at Liverpool Crown Court, where he was sentenced to 17 years in prison, on February 9. Matters were complicated by nobody from the police testifying exactly how their malware worked. Thomas OBrien, 43, Finch Lea Drive, Huyton was sentenced to 18 years for conspiracy to supply cocaine and diamorphine, and conspiracy to supply cannabis. The Crown failed to rectify the mistake in time and the case was ruled a nullity. Smith faces a charge of conspiracy with others unknown to produce class B cannabis between April 1 and July 23 2020. Andrew Bird is a specialist in white-collar crime, civil and criminal asset forfeiture,and civil and public law proceedings regarding the criminal process. Despite all this the Lord Chief Justice, Lord Justice Edis and Mrs Justice Whipple sided firmly with prosecutors, saying: We do not accept that this issue requires a minute examination of the inner workings of every system in every case, stating: The communication is that which is transmitted. Graham Minards, from Canella Avenue, Norris Green, used the secret pseudonym "Calm Tea" while trading more than 1,300kg of class A drugs. The Court rejected the application for permission to bring a claim for judicial review in relation to the EIO. Those who seek to challenge the evidence obtained will need to make applications to exclude the evidence in the Crown Court under section 78 PACE. Dutch and French law enforcement allowed police forces across Europe, including in the UK, access to the previously sent and new "real time" messaging between suspected organised crime groups before the raids started. This is what he had to say on the matter: The current judgment of the Court of Appeal, which refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court, is very unlikely to be the last word on the admissibility of the EncroChat evidenceThe situation is fluid and evolving day by day. Search the Cmentarz Komunalny Grabiszyn cemetery located in Dolnolskie, Poland. Hassall was sentenced to 12 and a half years and shook his head when told his sentence. Carmichael was actively trying to secure an AR15, a fully automatic assault rifle, for onward sale. The first time in an Encrochat prosecution a defendant has walked free on a matter of procedure and technicality. A message was sent out on June 12th 2020 to Encrochat users explaining that there had been a major breach stating: Due to the level of sophistication of the attack and the malware code, we can no longer guarantee the security of your device. The Manchester gangsters FLEEING the country as the Encrochat hack sees Many of the cases based on "Encro" evidence are now going to court, and if this judgement had ruled the messages couldn't be used, some trials may have been abandoned. Paolo is very proud of this victory and believes it to be the first victory for the defence in an Encrochat prosecution which has resulted in the collapse of the prosecution case and the release of all the defendants. Key features of Encrochat products include dual operating systems, global use across 120 countries and security features that make erasing data as simple as sending a text or entering a password. The judge then embarked upon a technical description of the way in messages were sent, received and stored. Get in touch with Paolo Martini by email on p.martini@cobleys.comor call today on 0151 242 9000 for his expert opinion on EncroChat and EncroPhone legal defence. ", The BBC's Tom Symonds is shown how a customised Android phone with EncroChat installed works. As it was succinctly put by Chief Justice Lord Burnett of Maldon in the Court of Appealthe issue in this appeal is whether evidence obtained from a mobile phone system known as EncroChat, which was marketed to its users as totally secure, can be admitted in evidence in criminal proceedings or is excluded by the Investigatory Powers Act 2016. | Accessibility, 2023 5SAH. Temple, London It remains to be seen whether the Scottish Courts can be persuaded to take a different view. Tech lawyer Neil Brown of decoded.legal blogged about this, writing: I think this means that, if a communication is available by virtue of access to a device, then it is inherently a stored communication, irrespective of whether a copy of it is also in the course of transmission. This button displays the currently selected search type. The leading case and authority from the Court of Appeal on the matter of admissibility of evidence of Encrochat was supervised by Paolo as is the most recent case before Manchester Crown Court which is currently going through the preparatory hearing process with a view to being determined at the Court of Appeal. And there will always be credit available to those who ultimately plead guilty. There was no evidence about this. When an EIO is issued it may not be known that there is an identified (or identifiable) suspect, thats often the point of the investigation , There can be circumstances in which it is permissible for an EIO to request the executing State to engage in the gathering of evidence, which is not yet in their possession. Or by navigating to the user icon in the top right. DX 417 LONDON, The EIO did not request that the French authorities conduct the interference with the UK-based handsets (on behalf of the UK authorities), Ground 1: The statutory criteria for the issuance or validation of the EIO were not satisfied. Regulated by the Bar Standards Board. That hearing ran for 15 days - between 16th November and 3rd December 2020 - and involved a great deal of oral evidence, including expert evidence. Lee O'Donnell, 28, of Mostyn Avenue, Old Roan, appeared at Liverpool Crown Court on Thursday, February 16 after pleading guilty to conspiracy to supply cocaine and cannabis, money laundering and . These offences are said to have taken lace between July 22 2019 and February 11 this year. (LogOut/ Officers managed to find out he used his cab to transport drugs during the Covid-19 lockdown. The 26-year-old, of Hoblyn Road, Bidston, appeared to be working for a user with the EncroChat handle 'PoundCake', and had been involved in collecting and transporting around 305,000 in dirty cash as part of the conspiracy. Select Accept to consent or Reject to decline non-essential cookies for this use. We use your sign-up to provide content in the ways you've consented to and improve our understanding of you. EncroChat - the Court of Appeal Judgment - Scottish Criminal Law Blog Kurtis Bolton was involved in the supply of more than 23kg of the Class A drug between March 27 and June 5, 2020, but police noted the device had been used as far back as October, 2019. Following the recent judgment from the Divisional Court, Alexandra Wilson provides us with a further update on the fast-paced and evolving world of Encrochat and its admissibility. In order for a designated public prosecutor to make or validate an EIO, she must be satisfied of the criteria in both Regulation 7(1)(a) and (b) of The Criminal Justice (European Investigation Order) Regulations 2017. 31 people sentenced to 366 years in prison in first year after That is so however quickly after transmission the obtaining of the copy takes place, or even if the copy is extracted while the original encrypted communication is being transmitted. . EncroChat evidence is being relied upon in about 900 prosecutions, and the ruling of the Divisional Court in this case establishes that the mechanism used to bring the evidence into England and Wales was lawful. The first EncroChat trial in 2020 resulted in the court finding that the Crown Court and section 78 Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 was the correct procedural process to seek to exclude EncroChat evidence. Is climate change killing Australian wine? OK, send in the contractors. The hack led to the UK's biggest ever operation against suspected organised criminals that has so far seen more than 1,500 arrests and scores of raids and seizures of drugs, cash and firearms across the UK in a series of unconnected operations across the country that have led to hundreds of charges. This is significant since this case will be the first significant prosecution where ambitious use of equipment interference has been deployed. Unfortunately, developments in 2020 suggested that this technology was not as air-tight as previously thought. All rights reserved. Even when a message is being transmitted, as far as the law is concerned its still being stored somewhere and was therefore fair game for the NCA, the Court of Appeal appeared to have ruled. The trial of A, B, D & C is yet to come, but the Court of Appeal allowed reporting on the basis thatthere are a significant number of cases pending in England and Wales derived from EncroChat material for this reason it is important that legal admissibility issues in this case should be determined in a judgment of this Court which can now be published. A gang who used Encrochat on the dark web to hide their multi-million pound drug deal operation in Merseyside has been jailed for more than 89 years combined. Law enforcement's hack of Encrochat, an encrypted phone network used heavily by organized crime, is now facing a wave of legal challenges across the United Kingdom as defendants raise issues with. The fact that what was obtained was an unencrypted message, means that what was on the phone, and what was intercepted, was not the same as what had been transmitted because what had been transmitted was encrypted. The Court of Appeal said: It is not known when or how the malware extracted the messages. England, Telephone:0151 242 90000151 242 9000 In an article on the EncroChat system, he correctly predicted the breach and implant by French law enforcement days before the news broke. This would involve deciding whether, at the point when they were intercepted, the. Since the first Encrochat arrests, managing partner and of Cobleys Solicitor, Paolo Martini, has been working very closely with the barristers most involved in the fight against the admissibility of the Encrochat evidence. Advertisement Encrochat: Secret network messages can be used in court, judges rule 5 February 2021 NCA By Tom Symonds Home affairs correspondent, BBC News An attempt to stop prosecutors using messages from. No one who gave evidence knew exactly how the malware works, and the French authorities were concerned that this should continue to be the case.. The fact that Dove J found that the material was obtained in compliance with French domestic law is undoubtedly important, as is the fact that the Investigatory Powers 2016 is (by section 272) extended to Scotland. Robert . That ruling also . VideoOn board the worlds last surviving turntable ferry, Indian officials wife distraught as his killer is freed, I didnt think make-up was made for black girls, Why there is serious money in kitchen fumes. Weeks later he reversed this decision again. A three year operation by the French and Dutch police and courts, codenamed Operation Emma, resulted in the French imaging an EncroChat server in Roubaix and finding a way to man-in-the-middle traffic passing across the EncroChat network by deploying malware to it, as reported this summer. The judgment, handed down on the afternoon of 5 February, has far-reaching repercussions for criminal defendants identified and arrested on suspicion of serious crimes with their identification being possible thanks to police reading the contents of their messages. Learn more in our Cookie Policy. In a 2015 factsheet on the bill before it became law, the Home Office defined interception as "making available the content of a communication to someone other than the sender or intended recipient during the course of its transmission. Encrochat shut itself down when it discovered the hack in June after people began being charged. Created withWix.com. Jan Luke Carmichael, 34, of Knowsley Lane, Huyton, was identified by detectives as using the EncroChat handle 'Lemonlager' after sending selfies and images of his own hands from which fingerprint evidence was obtained. The answer to that question, so far as proceedings in England and Wales are concerned, was given on Friday 5th February 2021. The National Crime Agency (NCA) led Operation Venetic was launched after French and Dutch police hacked into supposedly secure encrypted Encrochat mobile phone system in April 2020. Sexual Risk Orders & Interim Sexual Risk Orders. From drug dealers caught through their love of cheese to major drugs . Crime bosses who used encrypted platform EncroChat jailed EC4Y 7BL . On February 17, he was jailed for nine years at Liverpool Crown Court. That ruling also described how EncroChat worked when a user wanted to send a message, or so it summarised: Upon launch, the app's program and some of its data would be drawn from Realm [local storage] into RAM for use by the CPU in order to send and receive messages. Huyton drug dealer Jack Wymer, 29, and his underworld contacts were brought down by a major Cheshire Police operation dubbed Operation Thunderball, into criminals using the encrypted phone network to trade in drugs and firearms. is a specialist in white-collar crime, civil and criminal asset forfeiture,and civil and public law proceedings regarding the criminal process. Iqbal was handed a 12-year term on Friday at Guildford Crown Court. This is a process which is like any other means of downloading the content of a mobile phone handset. Thomas Cashman's final desperate message to try and intimidate 'accomplice' Paul Russell, Mum discovered cancer after buying 39 test she saw on Facebook, These are the faces of 39 Merseyside criminals who were jailed during April, 'My husband's body was treated like a bag of rubbish after he died on our living room floor', Live updates as police cordon off road lined with houses in Rice Lane, Lee ODonnell, 28, of Mostyn Avenue, appeared at Liverpool Crown Court after pleading guilty to conspiracy to supply a Class A drug (cocaine), Class B drug (cannabis), money laundering and acquiring/using/possessing criminal property. The judge summarized the nature of the EncroChat system in this wayEncroChat is a system of encrypted communication. The same men, plus Michael Pope, 34, of Whinney Grove West, Maghull, and Connor Smith, 27, of Derby Grove, Maghull, also face one charge each of conspiracy to supply class B amphetamines and another count each of conspiracy to supply class A cocaine and heroin between the same dates. The Claimant sought for the Regulations to be construed narrowly but the Court highlighted the importance of having regard for the underlying Directive. William Davidson, 39, and his right-hand man Steven Gorry, 47, were linked to the supply of 108kg of cocaine and 14kg of heroin arranged via the encrypted phone network, which was hacked by French and Dutch crime fighters in 2020. Matthew Ryder QC argued that based on this, prosecutors claims that sent messages were being stored was wrong. Detectives identified Burrell as supplying in excess of 14.5kg cocaine as well as significant quantities of cannabis. That hearing ran for 15 days - between 16th November and 3rd December 2020 and involved a great deal of oral evidence, including expert evidence. VAT Number 477 2974 93. Paolo spoke with Mr Rupert Bowers QC (Barrister at Doughty Street Chambers) on the topic. The charges followed the seizure by police of large amounts of chemicals and substances alleged to have been for the production of drugs after raids on industrial units in Aintree and North Wales last summer (pictured below). The answer to that question, so far as proceedings in England and Wales are concerned, was given on Friday 5th February 2021. b) There can be no investigation into an offence (i) that is unknown to the investigating authority or (ii) that has not been committed. France has refused to say how, what it called "the implant", worked, creating legal uncertainty in British courts. The High Court dismissed an application by the Claimant, C, for permission to judicially review the EIOthat had been issued by the CPS, requiring the French authorities to give them access to EncroChat data. The 39-year-old, of Liverpool, was sentenced to 13 years and six months in prison at the city's Crown Court earlier today.. Under long-standing British law, designed to protect intelligence techniques from scrutiny and make criminal trials manageable, intercepted evidence can't be used in court. When the case came before Liverpool Crown Court the judge (Dove J) directed that a preparatory hearing should be held to determine the admissibility of the EncroChat evidence. Shocking. Lee ODonnell, 28, of Mostyn Avenue, Old Roan, appeared at Liverpool Crown Court on Thursday, February 16 after pleading guilty to conspiracy to supply cocaine and cannabis, money laundering and possession of criminal property. In practice that means listening to a phone call or reading an email". Change). ODonnell used the Encrochat handle "ToxicMantis" from March 2020 to June 2020 and was given the nickname Scarface Anfield by other users due to a scar on his face and Anfield being where he used to live. As it stands, according to the Court of Appeal, there is no point of law of general public importance that would justify referring their decision to allow intercepted communications (such as EncroChat data) to be used as evidence to secure convictions in criminal cases. The Claimant is currently facing criminal proceedings in Liverpool Crown Court. That implant caused the device to transmit to the French police all the data held on it. The key findings of Dove J on this question are to be found at paragraph 63 of the judgment(Dove J) found that the communications were extracted directly from the handset of the user and not while they were travelling to, through or from any other part of the system. The National Crime Agency believes Encrochat was mainly used by criminals, often to trade drugs and guns. As well as the Encrochat messaging app, the company developed a modified version of the Android operating system and sold altered smartphones known as "carbon units" to run its software. By Ashmans Solicitors The Court of Appeal explained that in a previous judgment about EncroChat evidence, a Crown court had held that messages in a devices RAM were to be treated as being stored for legal purposes. When the case came before Liverpool Crown Court the judge (Dove J) directed that a preparatory hearing should be held to determine the admissibility of the EncroChat evidence. Anthony Saunderson, 40, Paul Mount, 37, Darren Owens, 46, of Knowsley Lane, Huyton, Kieran Hartley, 30, of Moss Side, Knotty, Ash, Stephen Shearwood, 37, of Sankey Road, Maghull, David Kelly, 42, of Downholland business park, Ormskirk, Lee Walsh, 42, of Boyer Avenue, Maghull, James Dunn, 34, of Sandy Lane, Walton, and Lee Eccles, 31, of Mersey Avenue, Maghull, are each charged with three counts. Mount, 37, of Summerwood Gardens, Halsall, is also accused of between March 26 and April 2 2020, conspiring to acquire an illegal Glock pistol and ammunition. Judges ruled the messages, obtained by French police by hacking the phones, were not gained by "interception". On the other hand, the admissibility of evidence in Scotland is largely regulated by the common law and section 78 of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 has no application. Families of those arrested during the fall-out from the Encrochat penetration have been arguing online that the NCA broke the law by accessing and reading messages "in real time", as they were being sent. In 2016, Parliament passed the Investigatory Powers Act in a massive overhaul of surveillance law. That. Read about our approach to external linking. The defence lawyers claimed the implant was taking messages from the phones' memory, milliseconds before being sent to their wifi or mobile data transmitters and therefore the data was "in transmission". The Court conclude that the Claimant has an adequate alternative remedy for his complaint: the Crown Courts power to exclude evidence under section 78 Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 (PACE). The EncroChat devices have dual operating systems, one being the EncroChat operating system itself and the second being a standard Android system with no functionality. A gang who used Encrochat on the dark web to hide their multi-million pound drug deal operation in Merseyside has been jailed for more than 89 years combined. L1 6BW As the Court of Appeal said in one of my previous cases on the same point the court will not countenance a failure to comply with statutory requirement. The EIO was submitted by the Defendant to the authorities in France on 11 March 2020. Police infiltrated the network between at least March and June 2020 during a Europe-wide investigation. ES OFFICE PROJEKT SP Z O O Company Profile - Dun & Bradstreet His Encrochat handle Stunhun confirmed Wright as supplying more than 17kgs cocaine, 4kgs heroin and 30kgs of cannabis. Importantly Dove J found that the French police had all the necessary legal instruments in place to undertake the lawful extraction of the material from the devices all over the world as a matter of French law. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); 19-23 Sir Thomas Street The clearest example would be when someone is under surveillance, and hence there is no requirement that an offence must have already been committed , The need for the Claimant to seek an extension of time, Whether the Claimant has standing in his claim for judicial review, Whether there was an adequate alternative remedy.
French 
English