In practice, a herd-immunity threshold is complicated and varies by setting. Now they're back in Kyiv, 34 injured and houses destroyed after Russia launches early morning strikes on Ukraine, US authorities 'auction' First Republic Bank after second biggest bank failure in history, Donald Trump denied mistrial in rape accuser Carroll's civil case, "national" set of rules for close contacts, Timely reminder: How to respond if you test positive to COVID-19. Vaccine distribution to a sufficient portion of a population to induce herd immunity could take place in as few as six months. A transition toward normalcy will occur when COVID-19 mortality falls and the disease is de-exceptionalized in society. The strain is likely to continue spreading in the coming months, propelled by its reproductive advantage over the original. While the variant of concern appears to be most widespread in the United Kingdom, it has been detected in over 30 countries, many of which (including the United States) have limited capacity for genetic sequencing. For an example of a high-end estimate, see Seth Flaxman et al., Estimating the effects of non-pharmaceutical interventions on COVID-19 in Europe, Nature, August 13, 2020, Volume 584, pp. An alarming spike in COVID-19 and flu cases in Australia could put the U.S. on track for what health experts call a twindemic a dangerous viral one-two punch in We acknowledge Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples as the First Australians and Traditional Custodians of the lands where we live, learn, and work. John Farley, FDA updates on Paxlovid for health care providers, US Food and Drug Administration, May 4, 2022. represent a material advancement and increase the chance that the impact of the Omicron variant can be controlled. Those two factors could advance the timeline, and make Q3 a little more likely than Q4. Salma Khalik, Moving from Covid-19 pandemic to endemic: Singapores strategy and how it can unfold,, Frances Mao, Fortress Australia: Why calls to open up borders are meeting resistance, BBC News, May 26, 2021, bbc.com; Meena Thiruvengadam, New Zealand to keep its borders closed through the end of 2021,. Three factors lead us to believe that timelines for herd immunity and transition toward normalcy in the United Kingdom will be similar to those in the United States. Twelve months ago, most people werent thinking about COVID-19. More recent data, as previously described, highlight the benefits of booster doses in protecting against the Omicron variant. While the United States could still achieve herd immunity in the third or fourth quarter of 2021 (in line with the peak probability in our previous estimates), the emergence of more-infectious variants of SARS-CoV-2 increases the risk that this milestone will not be achieved until later. Source: Bloomberg; DC; HHS; Moderna; Pfizer; Reuters; WSJ. In parallel, however, more-infectious strains of the virus have been detected in South Africa, the United Kingdom, and elsewhere and have spread to an increasing number of countries.134Miriam Berger, U.K. Global attitudes: COVID-19 vaccines, Ipsos, February 9, 2021, ipsos.com; Yasmeen Serhan, The vaccine-hesitant man of Europe,. Shabhir A. Mahdi et al., Efficacy of the ChAdOx1 nCoV-19 Covid-19 vaccine against the B.1.351 variant,, Novavax COVID-19 vaccine demonstrates 89.3% efficacy in UK Phase 3 trial, Novavax, January 28, 2021, ir.novavax.com; Carl Zimmer, Noah Weiland, and Sharon LaFraniere, New analyses show Johnson & Johnsons one-dose vaccine works well,. Copyright 2023 The New Daily. Joe Myers, 3 in 4 adults around the world say they would get a COVID-19 vaccine, World Economic Forum, September 1, 2020, weforum.org. These five factors combined mean that there is still a meaningful chance that herd immunity is not reached in the medium term. We expect this transition to continue in the second quarter of 2021 and will likely see many aspects of social and economic life return to the prepandemic normal, consistent with UK Prime Minister Johnsons staged reopening plan for the United Kingdom106Lockdown: Boris Johnson unveils plan to end England restrictions by 21 June, BBC, February 22, 2021, bbc.com. The winter of 202223 may see a more substantial uptick in the Northern Hemisphere, but this is unlikely to be as severe as the December 2021February 2022 A new dominant variant will receive a Greek-letter name, but until then we have created more descriptive names for our scenarios. Debt avalanche a sign loan system is broken, senator says as Given all of these variables, where do we net out? Even later herd immunity remains possible if other challenges arise, especially vaccine safety concerns or ambivalence to vaccination following a transition toward normalcy. This article was edited by Mark Staples, an editorial director in the New York office. To achieve that, we will need to see significant progress on the epidemiological end point, including an effective vaccine receiving Emergency Use Authorization approval during the fourth quarter of 2020 or the first quarter of 2021, followed by a smooth rollout and adoption by high-risk populations. Even countries, such as the United States, with high McKinsey COVID-19 Immunity Index scores continue to experience many new COVID-19 cases as a result of the extremely high transmissibility of current SARS-CoV-2 variants. Under the Omicrons twin scenario, a variant that evaded prior immunity (including from Omicron) but was otherwise similar to Omicron in transmissibility and severity of disease might cause a wave of disease broadly similar to the one we have recently experienced, though perhaps slightly worse if the public response to it is even more muted and if vaccine-conferred immunity has waned. Gaining that confidence will require a continuation of the progress made to reduce mortality and complications, as well as further scientific study regarding long-term health consequences for recovered patients. He criticised a relaxation of policies on face masks and social distancing, which he said was sending the message to the general public that the pandemic was over. That trend is likely to continue whilst the special COVID rulesfor working holidaymakers introduced by the Coalition Government remain in place and the labour market remains strong. This article describes most likely timelines for when the coronavirus pandemic will end. Many governments are employing packages of measuresthat aim to minimize the number of COVID-19 cases and excess mortality while maximizing social and economic degrees of freedom. Kate Brady and Reis Thebault, Europe to give covid booster shots as half the world is still starving for vaccines,. But its still highly contagious, NPR, August 11, 2021, npr.org; Josh Ulick and Alberto Cervantes, What makes the Delta variant of Covid-19 so dangerous for unvaccinated people, Wall Street Journal, July 30, 2021, wsj.com. This initial version of the McKinsey COVID-19 Immunity Index helps us make a few observations: One significant limitation of the McKinsey COVID-19 Immunity Index is that it doesnt indicate which people within a community are protected. Since so few results from home tests are reported, it has been difficult to estimate the current waves true magnitude in the United States. The fall in COVID-19 cases across much of the world over the past ten weeks signals a new dawn in the fight against the disease. She said her doctor was flippant when she asked about it. On the last day of December, that was starting to look optimistic, with the 20,000 mark already broken, well More-infectious viruses require that a higher percentage of people be simultaneously immune to reach herd immunity.136Ken Eames, Paul Fine, and David L. Heymann, Herd immunity: A rough guide, Clinical Infectious Diseases, 2011, Volume 52, Number 7, pp. Collectively, these treatments and changes in clinical practice have lowered mortality for those hospitalized by 18 percent or more.155Leora Horwitz et al., Trends in COVID-19 risk-adjusted mortality rates, Journal of Hospital Medicine, October 2020, journalofhospitalmedicine.com. Immunity can only partly predict the burden of disease at any point in time. The second end point of the pandemic may be reached earlier than the first. COVID data tracker weekly review, accessed August 15, 2021; Niharika Mandhana, From pandemic to endemic, Singapore creates model for living with Covid-19,, Alexis Madrigal, A simple rule of thumb for knowing when the pandemic is over,. Evidence has also accumulated steadily about the benefit of booster doses, leading more countries to expand and accelerate their rollout.72Factbox: Countries weigh need for booster COVID-19 shots, Reuters, December 8, 2021. Until a new variant emerges, and under some scenarios even once it does, the United States and Europe will likely continue to move toward these definitions of endemicity. Consumer surveys suggest that a portion of the population is cautious about vaccination. The threshold to achieve it is governed by a number of factors, including the transmissibility of the disease.138Eames, Fine, and Heymann, Herd immunity: A rough guide, pp. Further, manufacturing small molecules rapidly is faster than the process for monoclonal antibodies. WebOver the twelve months to the December 2022 quarter, the CPI rose 7.8%. Ben Adams, Merck has better luck with 2nd COVID-19 drug attempt as it sees a positive in early molnupiravir data, Fierce Biotech, March 8, 2021, fiercebiotech.com. For an example of a low-end estimate, see Max Fisher, R0, the messy metric that may soon shape our lives, explained, New York Times, April 23, 2020, nytimes.com. In countries where vaccination rates remain low, the prospects for ending the pandemic remain largely tied to the availability and administration of additional doses. The festive season. Dr Lydeamore said the fact that multiple branches of evolution of the virus were ending up in a similar position was a sign of "convergent evolution", and could be a good thing. FDA issues Emergency Use Authorization for third COVID-19 vaccine, US Food and Drug Administration (FDA), February 27, 2021, fda.gov. Coronavirus Australia And the rules changed again less than 24 hours later. EU Digital COVID Certificate, European Commission, accessed August 15, 2021, ec.europa.eu; Covid passports: How do they work around the world?, BBC News, July 26, 2021, bbc.com. What are the implications of the ChatGPT4 / Generative AI Causation hasnt been proven. then higher vaccine coverage ratesapproximately 60 to 85 percentcould be required to achieve herd immunity. The results of these scenarios for the United States are shown in Exhibit 1. Antibody levels may wane after just two months, according to some studies, while a United Kingdom population-monitoring effort reported that antibody prevalence fell by 26 percent over three months.163F. COVID-19 will not disappear during this transition, but will become a more normal part of the baseline disease burden in society (like flu, for example), rather than a special threat requiring exceptional societal response. Broadly speaking, availability will be similar to that of the United Kingdom and the United States, but EU countries may need to wait a few months longer to vaccinate all adults. National cabinet encourages wearing masks to combat COVID-19. Third, the fraction of US and UK residents who already have natural immunity from prior infection is in the same range (with significant variability among regions within countries).149SeroTracker, Public Health Agency of Canada, accessed 1/12/21, serotracker.com. The short answer is that the latest developments serve mainly to reduce the uncertainty of the timeline (Exhibit 1). Struggling main streets are terrible for towns and neighbourhoods. Choose a holistic set of health, economic, and social markets that they are managing for, Monitor and track progress against them in ways that allow for targeted response escalation when needed, Limit disease through effective use of vaccines, therapeutics, and other countermeasures, Slow transmission through testing and environmental/workplace modifications, the potential for new variants to emerge (for example, a variant that evades vaccine-mediated immunity to the extent that it frequently causes severe disease in the vaccinated and spreads widely would likely have the most significant effect on any countrys prospects for reaching the end of the pandemic), further evidence of waning natural and vaccine-mediated immunity over time, and challenges with rolling out vaccine boosters quickly enough to maintain immunity, further challenges with vaccine manufacturing or global rollout, changes in the ways that countries define an acceptable burden of disease (for example, setting different targets for disease burden in vaccinated and unvaccinated populations), Population vaccinatedthe proportion of people who have received the vaccine so far, Vaccine courses securedthe additional supplies for which a country has contracted, Consumer vaccine sentimentthe publics willingness to be vaccinated, Population under 19 years of agea greater proportion of children makes a transition toward normalcy easier to achieve but herd immunity more difficult, Natural immunity, or the rate of prior COVID-19 infectionhigher. The decline in the efficacy of COVID-19 vaccines over time and the benefits of booster doses have become much better understood over the past three months. Timelines to reach the desired coverage threshold will be affected by health systems abilities to adapt to changing needs and updated information. Were still seeing thousands of people being infected; were seeing many, many people ending up in hospital, he said. Since I like a challenge, I looked at demographic, social, and economic data to come up with 22 predictions of what 2022 will hold in store for Australia. In reality, people mix mostly with others whose patterns of interaction are similar to their own. That said, major questions are still outstanding, even about vaccines, such as long-term safety, timely and effective distribution, and vaccine acceptance by the population, to say nothing of lingering epidemiological questions such as the duration of immunity. In other words, BA.5 can cause a much more severe disease. A transition to the next normal, in whatever form that takes, will come gradually when people have confidence that they can do what they used to do without endangering themselves or others. 23Emma K. Accorsi, Amadea Britton, Katherine E. Fleming-Dutra, et al, Association Between 3 Doses of mRNA COVID-19 Vaccine and Symptomatic Infection Caused by the SARS-CoV-2 Omicron and Delta Variants, January 21, 2022, jamanetwork.com.. Countries where a significant portion of those at risk had received three doses of vaccine, including at least one dose of mRNA vaccine, saw hospitalizations substantially decouple from cases.24New COVID-19 cases worldwide, Johns Hopkins University & Medicine, February 20, 2022, coronavirus.jhu.edu. Herd immunity could be reached as soon as the second quarter of 2021 if vaccines are highly effective and launched smoothly or if significant cross-immunity is discovered in a population And real downside risk remains, especially with respect to duration of immunity and long-term vaccine safety (given the limited data available so far). The proportion of the population with effective immunity for both COVID-19 vaccines and prior infection is separated from the aforementioned proportions of the population with effective immunity from COVID-19 vaccines only and from the population with effective immunity from prior COVID-19 infection only. As we wrote in July 2020, one or more vaccines may receive US Food and Drug Administration Emergency Use Authorization before the end of 2020 (or early in 2021) and the granting of a Biologics License Application (also known as approval) during the first quarter of 2021. "I've gotsevere mortgage stress and a $100 doctor's bill was a really significant cost for me," she said. The variant of concern represents a potential source of difference. House prices will continue to rise. As for exactly why COVID-19 deaths are on the rise in Australia, Professor Esterman said it is very hard to say why. In this article, well explain the criteria that will be key factors in determining when each is reached. If we are able to pair these vaccines with more effective implementation of public-health measures and effective scale-up of new treatments and diagnostics, alongside the benefits of seasonality, we may also be able to reduce mortality enough in Q2 to enable the United States to transition toward normalcy. The United Kingdoms plan for reopening provides an example of the stepwise manner in which a transition to normalcy is likely to occur.132Lockdown: Boris Johnson unveils plan to end England restrictions by 21 June, February 22, 2021. Lockdown: Boris Johnson unveils plan to end England restrictions by 21 June, BBC, February 22, 2021, bbc.com. NCA NewsWire. This is a fragile dawn, however, with transmission and deaths still high, unequal access to vaccines, and variants of concern threatening to undo progress to date. to advise boosters for most Americans 8 months after vaccination, New York Times, August 16, 2021, nytimes.com. But for now, the pandemic phase looks to be ending. The United Kingdoms experience nevertheless suggests that once a country has weathered a wave of Delta-driven cases, it may be able to resume the transition toward normalcy. Australia Oral therapeutics that significantly reduce the chance of progression to severe disease after symptom onset may enable a higher fraction of cases to be managed as outpatients. Protection against any infection (including asymptomatic disease) is likely to be lowerand protection against severe disease is likely to be higher. At this stage, when monthly mortality from COVID-19 may start to resemble that of flu in an average year, we may see a transition toward normalcy, albeit with public-health measures still in place. Australias largest generation reaches the family Others have also advanced this view; for an example, see Grady McGregor, Evidence mounts that Omicron is more infectious, less severe than Deltabut Fauci, other experts warn against premature optimism,, Ewen Callaway and Heidi Ledford, How bad is Omicron? They are indexed on the recent Delta wave and show whether various potential combinations of infectiousness, immune evasion, and clinical severity are likely to lead to a higher or lower rate of COVID-19-related hospitalization. the first and more important of the pandemics two endpoints. 45762, nature.com. Things will be fine by January 2022. Working from home is here to stay but exclusively virtual working arrangements will remain the exception. Vaccinating more people is a nonlinear challenge. Web2022 Nostradamus seven 2022 predictions: From the death of Kim Jong-un to war in Europe and the collapse of the EU From the death of a dictator to cataclysmic quakes, Nostradamus is believed to have predicted dire events for 2022. Millennials continue on to family-sized houses. Our scenario modeling suggests that although the resulting level of population immunity may not be high enough to achieve herd protection, it would still protect a substantial portion of the population. Most serious cases of COVID-19 would occur in unvaccinated people. In this extract from Pandemedia, The Australian Financial Reviews Patrick Durkin explains how his coronavirus experience began with a car race. Nature, June 17, 2022. Improved estimates of seroprevalence are increasingly available for many regions. For COVID-19, it can be generally thought of as the expected number of cases directly generated by a single case in a population in which all people are susceptible. Estimates of their overall immunity remain low enough that there is still a risk of significant waves of disease. The key factor is diminished mortality. There is still much more to learnsample sizes in the new studies were small, antibody titers are an imperfect metric of immune protection, and major manufacturers are yet to release similar information. This article was edited by Josh Rosenfield, an executive editor in the New York office. making it possible to protect a group that comprises a significant share of the population in some countries. For this reason, the continued global rollout of COVID-19 vaccines remains an investment in our collective safety as well as an imperative to protect individuals. Summary statistics, SeroTracker, September 16, 2020, serotracker.com. But herd immunity would mean that the emergency measures currently in place in many countries could be lifted. but the real-world impact of their use at scale is not yet known, and supplies of paxlovid are still scaling.38CDC Health Advisory: Using Therapeutics to Prevent and Treat COVID-19, The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), December 31, 2021, emergency.cdc.gov; Berkeley Lovelace, Jr., Covid pills are easier to find as the Omicron surge subsides, NBC News, February 23, 2022, nbcnews.org. Parts of the European Union have recently faced setbacks: fewer doses in arms than in the United Kingdom or United States, a new wave of cases, and new lockdowns. Beyond vaccines, science is also progressing in therapeutics for COVID-19. In just 10 months, the cost of servicing an average $600,000 mortgage will have risen by more than $14,000 per year once those rate hikes are fully passed through. While a more infectious variant likely means more people are acquiring natural immunity through infection (despite ongoing efforts to minimize new cases), the net impact of more-infectious strains is likely to be that a higher portion of the population needs to be vaccinated, which may take more time. While we dont yet know the full extent of waning immunity for Omicron, new evidence indicates that those who have received three doses of vaccine may benefit from medium-term protection.32Frauke Muecksch, Zijun Wang, Alice Cho, et al., Increased potency and breadth of SARS-CoV-2 neutralizing antibodies after a third mRNA dose, BioRxiv, February 15, 2022, biorxiv.org. 8. We made this point in the last four editions of this article, and unfortunately it remains as true as ever. Duration of immunity matters, obviously; for instance, our modeling suggests that if natural immunity to COVID-19 lasts six to nine months, as opposed to multiple years (like tetanus) or lifelong (like measles), herd immunity is unlikely to be achieved unless adult vaccination rates approach 85 percent. Many high-income countries did begin such a transition toward normalcy during the second quarter of this year, only to be hit with a new wave of cases caused by the Delta variant and exacerbated by vaccine hesitancy. At this point, significant, ongoing public-health measures are not needed to prevent future spikes in disease and mortality (this might be achieved while there are still a number of people in particular communities who still have the disease, as is the case with measles). Immunity protects individuals and reduces risk for people in the community around them by reducing rates of onward transmission. Herd immunity to a pathogen is achieved when a sufficient portion of a population is simultaneously immune to prevent sustained transmission. Endemic COVID-19 does not mean that the disease poses no risk. A leading epidemiologist has warned Australia is heading towards 50 COVID-19 deaths a day as more transmissible Omicron sub-variants become the nations dominant strains. Prospects for the rest of the year and beyond hinge on the questions of whether and when future variants will emerge. CDC strengthens recommendations and expands eligibility for COVID-19 booster shots, US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, May 19, 2022; Updated joint statement from ECDC and EMA on additional booster doses of COVID-19 vaccines, European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control, July 11, 2022. Official sees strong possibility Covid shots will be given every autumn,. COVID-19 Projections After December 16, 2022, IHME will pause its COVID-19 modeling for the foreseeable future. The worlds reaction has been an unpleasant mixture of dread, fatigue, and dj vu. The bleak news comes as Australia faces the weakest rate of economic growth outside the COVID pandemic since the recession in the early 1990s, Juliet R. C. Pulliam et al., Increased risk of SARS-CoV-2 reinfection associated with emergence of the Omicron variant in South Africa, medRxiv, December 2, 2021. Australia The authors wish to thank Xavier Azcue, Brian Hencke, David Meredith, Michalis Michaelides, Anthony Ramirez, Virginia Simmons, Konstantinos Tsakalis, and Lieven Van der Veken for their contributions to this article. AT END APRIL 2023, the Government increased its net migration forecast for 2022-23 to 400,000 up from its October Budget forecast of 235,000. In the context of Omicrons arrival and impending spread, three factors come to the forefront: the potential impact of new therapeutics in reducing hospitalizations and death, the criticality of boosters in the context of waning immunity, and clarity and consensus in public-health measures. The past five weeks have brought an array of conflicting news on the COVID-19 pandemic, affecting our estimates about when the coronavirus pandemic will end. It's a big shift from the first few years of the pandemic, where the gold-standard PCR testing was available to everyone in the community in an attempt to identify every case and send rings of contacts into quarantine. Europe splits on Omicron response, New York Times, December 20, 2021.28Michael Ollove, Amid Omicron Uncertainty, States Resist New Mandates, PEW, December 10, 2021, pewtrusts.org. As in previous waves, lower-income countries and those with younger populations were somewhat protected,25Nurith Aizenman, Africa may have reached the pandemic's holy grail, NPR, January 28, 2022, npr.org. Melbourne School of Population and Global Health We acknowledge Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples as the First Australians and Traditional Custodians of the lands where we live, learn, and work. 11. Australians are being warned the countrys economy is on a knife-edge after the Reserve Bank of Australias string of interest rate hikes, with a consumer recession predicted for 2023.. But so far, they havent fundamentally changed the dynamics of the pandemic, because there hasnt been a step change decline in immunity, as seen during the winter, when Omicron first emerged. This service may include material from Agence France-Presse (AFP), APTN, Reuters, AAP, CNN and the BBC World Service which is copyright and cannot be reproduced. As COVID-19s impact on health wanes, we are likely to see greater normalization of social and economic life. Its still in phase three trials. The healthcare sector continues to boom. The possible time frame for them to manage COVID-19 as an endemic disease is less clear. ; and progress on therapeutics. There was an error submitting the form. While countries such as Israel have shown what is possible, the United States has fallen behind its targets.144Coronavirus: Israel leads vaccine race with 12% given jab, BBC, January 3, 2021, bbc.com.145Michelle R. Smith, Governors scramble to speed vaccine effort after slow start, Associated Press, January 6, 2021, apnews.com. Some countries in this group, such as Australia, have recently faced a Delta-driven surge in cases, but in absolute terms the burden of disease remains low relative to other countries. The authors wish to thank Gaurav Agrawal, Xavier Azcue, Jennifer Heller, Anthony Ramirez, Shubham Singhal, and Rodney Zemmel for their contributions to this article.
French 
English