why isn't roger maris in the hall of fame

Position players spend 1/18 of a game hitting and half of it holding down the field of play. The camera probably wasn't supposed to capture the upper deck. ", Roger Maris hit his 61st home run exactly 61 years ago today in 1961. On the one hand, youll be remembered. And he's probably relatively even on fame with Joe Jackson. He does not have the career milestones, and his short peak, while very good, was not excellent. Rogers swing was crafted by Zeus for the right field dimensions of Yankee Stadium, and in his first season in The Bronx, Maris hit 39 home runs and led the league in runs batted in. Oct. 11, 2022 1:44 pm ET Text New York Yankees Roger I have always argued that Maris was essentially a better than average player, aside from a couple standout years, and not overall HOF material. I believe he needs to be inducted. Why isn't Roger Maris in the hall of fame? The online betting stuff really bothers me too. Check out the movie *61 that Billy Crystal did in 2001. He was not a (61) one-hit wonder: Roger Maris was a very good ballplayer. I admit I wanted Mickey to break the record, but after he was out of the race I was routing for Roger. Jack Curry has covered baseball for the The New York Times for 18 seasons. No one broke that 61 HR record until the Steroid Era & sadly those cheaters will probably be inducted eventually! Roger was an outstanding outfielder if you remember the 1962 World Series against he made a play in the rightfield corner holding Willie Mays at third to preserve a Yankee World Championship. Does Roberto Alomar Deserve To Be Inducted Into The Hall of Fame? Or my brothers friend. F Craig was a three-time Super Bowl champion and four-time Pro Bowl player. Ford Fricks name should be Ford Prick.As far as Im concerned he still owns the record at 61. There are players in the HOF that didnt have anywhere near the impact on Baseball & the fan excitement that Roger did, I know b/c I was alive. Similarly, in the AL it's clear that the best performances were by pitchers (six of the top eight in WAR were pitchers), but Burroughs was still a very strange choice. https://x-files.fandom.com/wiki/Babe_Ruth. "If I never hit another home run - this is the one they can never take away from me.". He had great impact in his era. Read2 hours ago | Michael Doran, Article viewed iconAn icon to mark the viewed articles Aaron , Robinson , Clemente and Colavito were all great players but Maris was probably better as an overall defensive player, even than Clemente.Roger Maris, who won two Most Valuable Player Awards, primarily for his offense, was better at fielding, in my opinion than hitting. Why Roger Maris Why has he been passed over? He played for four different teams (Cleveland Indians, Kansas City Royals, New York Yankees and St. Louis Cardinals). I disagree. Read21 hours ago | Lance Morrow, Article viewed iconAn icon to mark the viewed articles The ball traveled just 360 feet and slammed into box l63D of section 33 into the sixth row of the lower deck in right field. Successful dealings with Wcsportscards94558, EagleEyeKid, SamsGirl214, Volver, DwayneDrain, Oaksey25, Griffins, Cardfan07, Etc. Still other readers say that Mariss relatively short career should not Maybe he doesn't have the greatest career stats. For years I thought that breaking Ruths record all by itself should qualify him for the Hall, but you make a good argument. Its really hard to say he belongs as a Hall of Fame enshrinement, rather that event will keep his name in the Hall of Fame for his accomplishment Richard Lee-Ching RB Roger Craig. During the 1961 season, Maris hit 61 home runs for the New York Yankees, breaking Babe Ruth's single-season record of 60 home runs (set in 1927), a record that stood for 37 years. https://EzineArticles.com/expert/Mickey_Morgan/1169320, http://ezinearticles.com/?Why-Isnt-Roger-Maris-in-the-Baseball-Hall-of-Fame?&id=6537020. (In 1989 Fernando Tatis of the Cardinals hit two grand slams in the same inning!). Or maybe the book would only have to win the big ones 10% more often than they should. Barry Bonds was trained to be a baseball player since he was a child. Please at least get your facts correct? He would hit two home runs in his first game as a Yankee, finishing the season with 39 home runs, a .283 batting average, and an MVP award. . He WAS deserving. Another thing about his 61 homers, seeing as how you criticize the players who broke it because they used steroids: Maris hit 61 in an expansion year with two new teams in the league. I believe that Josh was referring to Right Field defensive play: Maris arrived a few years after Al.Kaline had already established himself as the American Leagues RightField defensive Gold Glove Champion.They were both all- time greats, defensively, but you would have had to knock out Al Kaline for Roger Maris to win the Gold Glove Award.Maris was very fast, tracked very well and had a great arm. I remember the newspapers and sports magazines were trying to create an adversary relationship between Roger and Mickey. That was mostly because he batted behind Mickey Mantle, but Maris was named MVP in 1960. However, Roger was still five games ahead of the record pace by Ruth, whose 51st HR didn't come until his 139th game. Maris received three or fewer votes from the 16-member committee appointed by the Hall of Fame to review a 10-candidate Golden Era ballot. He was But agreed with your thought, it would be an interesting thing to consider Barry Bonds seeing Maris in first. Roger Maris has no Hall of Fame case. Scan this QR code to download the app now. You can probably assume that means a HR, especially if that was a statement he used frequently. Known as Superchief, Reynolds was the Yankees best pitcher of the late 1940s and early 1950s. It was a special accomplishment. But, Maris is way, way more famous than any baseball player not in the HOF. game in each of three others.). Yes I know Namath is already in. You may cancel your subscription at anytime by calling In 15 years on the Baseball Writers' Association of America ballot, Maris peaked at 43.1% of the vote in 1988, his 15th and final year of BBWAA eligibility. The arguments against Maris include his struggles with durability and longevity, with his 1,463 games played being on the very low end for a candidate. Gil Hodges, Jim Kaat, Minnie Mioso and Tony Oliva were elected by the Golden Days Era Committee (1950-69), while Bud Fowler and Buck ONeil were chosen by the Early Baseball Era Committee (pre-1950), as announced on MLB Network. Great points & I agree with you about the Ford Prick comment! I think Mays and Aaron and others may also have hit 40 or more. 1. There are players who are not in the Hall of Fame and likely will not be anytime in the future but their significant singular achievements are more than worthy of their special place in baseball history. Read3 hours ago | Gerard Baker, Article viewed iconAn icon to mark the viewed articles Who is Roger Maris and is he in the Hall of Fame? - Sportskeeda Yes I know Namath is already in. All though looking at the teammates that Roger played with he was a key player on the Yankees and Cardinals. His Yankee teammates formed a human wall in front of the dugout, refusing to let him enter. If Aaron Judge eclipses him, itll be quite an Sign in or register to get started. And in the early 1960s, if you drove in a lot of runs and played for the pennant-winning team, you basically won the MVP. Ken Burns baseball docuseries says that Maris started getting death threats and hate mail and stuff when he got close to the record. Honestly I don't care one way or the other. I'll probably get all 6s. Which makes it look like Maris is hitting the ball to himself. Before then, he was a staff writer for the Dallas Morning News for two years. He earned a football scholarship to Oklahoma, but didnt like campus life and left in his freshman year to sign a contract with the Cleveland Indians. A Gold Glove recipient in 1960, Maris career is best remembered for hitting 61 home runs in 1961, shattering a single-season home run record previously held by Babe Ruth. PSE | Granted, it has been a few years since I have been to the HOF, but I would argue that, sans a plaque, Maris is as much in the HOF as some of those with plaques. As Ive written elsewhere in this book, in the 1950s the Kansas City As were nothing more than a feeder team for the Yankees. Today, no one pitches back-to-back complete games! He was a great player for the few seasons he played. He went through Hell because no one wanted him to break Ruths record. In the 60s-90s and most of the 2000s most people couldn't even watch this video easily. Maris was the MVP that year and also won the award the previous season for the Yankees. Around the same time, Commissioner Ford Frick ruled that an asterisk would be placed next to Maris' name in the record books if he broke the Babe's record after the 154th game of the season. It's likely that nobody in baseball history hasn't cheated on this record. His personal hitting coach helped Judge from the beginning of his Yankee career, teaching him a set of unorthodox swing mechanics which potentiate his power. My Man Taxerman, a faithful Yankees fan, also reinforced my observation that Maris was a superb right fielder. A native of Philadelphia and a graduate of Vanderbilt University, Kepner has also covered The next season the American League added two teams and expanded the schedule to 162 games. I was in my early teens in 61 and remember the home run race well. @reelinintheyears said: I think to speculate on anyone cheating is unfair. This is manifestly not true. Expert Maris had three games in which to "officially" break Ruth's record. It was the Yankees versus the Red Sox. Agree. He then returned in Game 4 to pitch 3 1/3 perfect innings of relief to record the save before New York went on to win the Series in Game 5. IMO Munson had a better case than Maris. Why is Roger Maris not in the Hall of Fame? - ABTC He absolutely legitimately hit 61 in '61, no ifs and or buts about it!!! In 1999 the United States Postal Service issued a commemorative stamp honoring Roger Maris. Given the number of legitimate reporters covering the race between him and Mantle and the number of fans attending the games, there is no possible way any of it could have been staged. It's like the 1974 MVP races where there was no reason to vote for either winner. McMichael and Dan Hampton (a 2002 Hall of Fame inductee) formed one of the greatest defensive duos in NFL history, a unit that totaled 41.5 sacks from 1984-88. shrug My mom has a cesarean scar. Take out the 2-year span in which he hit 100 HR and he averages 17.5 HR per year the rest of his career (which only lasted 12 years total). Why Isn't Roger Maris in the Baseball Hall of Fame? At least it still clings to 3 figures, the same seems not to apply about most who have posted here. How We Ranked Baseballs Greatest Players, Election of Baines lowers the bar for the Baseball Hall of Fame, Golden Days Era Ballot for Baseball Hall of Fame, The 100 Greatest Right Fielders of All-Time >, VIDEO: Curt Flood Misplays Ball in Game 7 of 1968 World Series, VIDEO: Montreal Expos First Game and First Home Opener, from 1969, https://baseballegg.com/all-time-player-rankings/baseballs-greatest-right-fielders-of-all-time/, Mo Vaughns Exit From the Red Sox was not Pretty, In 1969, Experts Thought These Were the Greatest Third Basemen, VIDEO: Fred McGriffs First Home Run for Tampa Bay. His best argument comes from his two MVP awards and for breaking Babe Ruths single-season home run record. Silva wrote: Comets are fast! This blogs regular features, including live game analysis, news and notes from Tyler Kepner, David Waldstein and others, can now be found on the baseball section of our website.Readmore, The free-agent second baseman Robinson Cano is reportedly still seeking a 10-year deal for $310 million, figures the Yankees are said to be unwilling to meet. Fans of Roger Maris were quick to respond to my column Sunday, I remember the pressure he was under from Mantle fans and the sports writers who didnt want him breaking the Babes record because he was not a hoeeme grown Yankee ( brutal treatment everyday in 1961) hes a hall of fame human being if not a ballplayer but in my boo hes both!!! I was 14 years old and an eye witness to the duel in 1961 between Mickey Mantle and Roger Maris for Babe Ruths 60-dinger record from 1927. The record may be broken, but many younger fans are finding the answer to an important: Who was Roger Maris? I don't think anybody can argue reasonably that it isn't. The introverted outfielder dealt with such stress that his hair began to fall out. Roger Maris, Allie Reynolds fall short in Hall of Fame The Hall of Fame DOES have a records room which celebrates record holders and award winners, etc. We would spend one season with Cleveland and the Oakland Athletics before being traded to the New York Yankees in a seven-player deal in December 1959. Too young to see Maris in his best years. If Aaron Judge eclipses him, itll be quite an accomplishment. Now it is October 1, 1961, the last game of the season. They had He doesn't backpedal and turn or anything. Aaron Judge is on pace for 65+. 61 in '61 was the number McGwire and Bonds were chasing. Article viewed iconAn icon to mark the viewed articles He lives in Michigan where he writes, runs, and enjoys a good orange soda now and again. Shpigel received a bachelor's degree in English and journalism from Emory University and a master's degree in journalism from Columbia University. I collect Steve Garvey, Dodgers and signed cards. I think you might be surprised what can be staged. Collectors Corner | He played at the same time as Frank Robinson, Henry Aaron, Al Kaline, Roberto Clemente, and Rocky Colavito, all of whom were better players. Take away 1961 and no one would even think of putting him in the HOF. Pretty huge accomplishment. @ScoobyDoo2 said: It's likely that nobody in baseball history hasn't cheated on this record. Have you heard of Honus Wagner, Derek Jeter, Cal Ripken and host of others? Why He really had little baseball left in him when he played his final games for the Cardinals in 1968. I think what his critics are saying is that his body of work isnt sufficient to be a Hall of Famer. Submitted On September 02, 2011. 8 Articles, By Only 5-foot-8 and 155 pounds, hes still alive at 93. Excellent article. Koufax was clearly one of the best arms in his prime, but his career was so brief, especially considering he didn't hit his stride until it was nearly halfway over! If Judge breaks the record this year, it will be 61 years after Maris hit 61 in '61. His teammates finally let him into the dugout. Be the first one to comment on this story. Maybe that doesnt put him over the top, but it deserves more than a brief mention. He doesn't have the number to be a hall of Maris had 58 home runs on September 18 when the Yankees came to Baltimore for a four game series. The writers hold grudges against players they dont like for instance look at Del Ennis he had the most RBIs in the decade of the 50e more than Stan Musial, Eddie Matthews,Hank Aaron, Mickey Mantle Willie Mays and yet hes not in the HoF. He had a fine 822 OPS, which for that era was very good. The Ford C. Frick Award is given out by MLB to broadcasters annually. He saved the 62 World Series with an unspectacular , yet great, play with 2 outs in the 7th game stopping the fast Giants Matty Alou, running on contact from.first base, at 3rd base on a righty hitting Willie Mays double down the right field line which Maris got to on one hop just before it reached the warning track; pivoted, hit 2nd Baseman.Bobby Richardson with a good,tough throw and Richsrdson was able to hold Alou to 3rd Base (Yankee Catcher, Elston Howard said that they would have gotten out Alou by a lot if he had continued to Home Plate. Why Isn't Roger Maris in the Baseball Hall of Fame? You judge a player by the impact he had in his time. Maris doesnt have incredible career numbers 275 homers and 851. homers in 61. Kind of like Tiger Woods. Nevertheless, from 1959 -.1962 his fellow American League players (and coaches, I believe ) chose him as an American League All-Star. Does he deserve to be in? Clearly, Maris was a very good player as evidenced by his 1960 MVP. Mantle was the favorite; Maris who had come to the Yankees in a trade with Kansas City was the outsider. During the 1961 baseball season, I was a 17 year old enjoying my summer vacation before entering my senior year of high school. Why Roger Maris isnt in the Hall of Fame - Pinterest However, he met the 10 year minimum and those 6 great years propelled him over the top. Last Friday, the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum named baseball legend Roger Maris to their 10-person Golden Days Era Committee ballot. So you think Maris's 61 HR season is a fraud? Red Barber knew a thing or two about calling a ball game, although all he said was "there it is". WebThe "M&M Boys" were the duo of New York Yankees baseball players Mickey Mantle and Roger Maris, who were teammates from 1960 to 1966.They gained prominence during the 1961 season, when Maris and Mantle, batting third and cleanup (fourth) in the Yankee lineup respectively, both challenged Babe Ruth's 34-year-old single-season record of 60 home Take out the fact that he was a Yankee, he would not have anyone thinking he belongs in the Hall. Kirk Gibson: In a season that has been so improbable, the impossible has happened said Vin Scully as a hobbling Gibson circled the bases after hitting his game-winning home run for the Dodgers in the first game of the 1988 World Series. As far as Cardgeek is concerned, I suppose the earth is flat and the moon landings were staged in Hollywood. WebRoger Maris was a really good baseball player who has only a small number of Hall of Fame years, including one that included a Hall of Fame accomplishment. Yankees fans appreciate their team honoring Roger Maris and the 50th anniversary of his 61 in '61. He was critical for 5 pennants and 2 world series for Yankees. Already a subscriber? Mickey and Roger became friends and continued that friendship even after the both retired after the '68 season. . Only 19,401 attended the game to see only the second man in baseball history to hit 60 home runs in one season. Were Carew's hits, BA, and OBP enough to offset the fact that the Twins finished eight games out? He was never a "scrawny kid" or "thin" like Bonds and McGuire were in their first few seasons. His stats, 275 career HR, .260 batting average, and 38.2 WAR are nowhere near numbers to qualify for the Hall. At least he was a Yankee. But he actually only had five seasons where he qualified for the batting title. The 1961 and 1962 seasons were unique due to the expansion, which represented the greatest immediate dilution relative to the existing talent pool in the majors and the growing total pool of talent (both expansion outside the US and core population growth). Why isn't Roger Maris in the Hall of Fame? - Collectors Universe Were gathering again for a baseball Hot Stove Luncheon (with a dash of NFL, too) on Thursday, Jan. 20 at 11:45 a.m. at Palm Valley Country Club in Palm Desert. Roger Maris in the same way that the actor James Dean went fast around here. As they say in the legal system: I'd rather see a guilty man go free than an innocent man go to prison. Nobody is going to mistake George Kell or Bill Mazeroski for Cal Ripken or Reggie Jackson. Kell and Maz both got in ~ it doesnt tarnish Cal or Reggie in the least. Here's the windup. This also helped to counter the negative impact from the shift in the National League from smaller stadiums to the larger multi-purpose stadiums. It was a great time to be a baseball fan. Mazeroski, Jackie Robinson and even Koufax are a few that might be considered. We could all stipulate that Mick could have beaten it. The commissioner, Ford Frick, refused to Sixty-one for Maris!". Then, he came back to close out Game 4, striking out Stan Lopata to record the save and secure the Yanks' 13th World Series title in franchise history. Roger was MVP in 1960 because Yankees finished 2nd in 1959 with Bauer and Woodling in RF and Roger helped Yankees win AL pennant again. Tony Cloninger:In 1966, the Milwaukee pitcher hit not one, but two grand slams in the same game! And yet you call yourself CardGeek. His best showings came in the 1949 and '50 Fall Classics. It's also interesting to me that the wall in that video is about 3 feet high. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. As others have said, he clearly falls short on the career stats, and there is simply no way of looking at it that places Maris above Dwight Evans, Bobby Bonds, Bobby Murcer, or several other better right fielders ignored by the HOF. Still waiting on my last PSA submission. He absolutely legitimately hit 61 in '61, no ifs and or buts about it!!! Thanks for reading and taking the time to comment, David. Roger Maris was not the very personable Mickey Mantle type guy. To paraphrase: It does no good telling people that Henderson and Seaver were no good. He had a 32-home run, 105 RBIs and 26 stolen bases season for KC and ran for 221 yards in a game for the Raiders, a record for Monday Night Football which still stands. I like stuff like this more than almost anybody. Maris hit 58 homers in the first 154 games (the length of the schedule when Babe Ruth set the single-season record), and finished with 61. However, the stories were not true. If "incredibly famous for a few short years" is a criterion, then Canseco, Mattingly, Strawberry, Gooden, and Hershiser should all be in. @CardGeek said: You will be notified in advance of any changes in rate or terms. Roger Maris remains one of the most celebrated names in baseball; he held the games most revered record for 37 years and won back-to-back MVPs. MLB Never Forgave Roger Maris for Beating Babe Ruth - WSJ In our list of the Top 100 Right Fielders of All-Time, he ranks 47th, sandwiched between Kirk Gibson and Kiki Cuyler, both of whom were (like Maris) excellent athletes, but not all-time legends. Should Roger Maris be considered for Maris also retired at a very early age (just 33) because of his nagging injuries and the opportunity to earn more money as a businessman. That's 40 years of technological advances between the two. However, people questioned the legitimacy of his home run record due to the season expanding to 162 games, as opposed to the 154 games that Babe Ruth hit 60 in. Roger Maris: Many still believe his 61 home runs in 1961 is still the single-season home run record. Sign In. Roger And a melee broke out as fans scuffled and scrambled, fighting for the ball and the $5,000 reward. Should Roger Maris finally be inducted in the Baseball Hall of Fame McGwire said that breaking the single season home run record was a gift from the guy upstairs. But he DID it. While the Hall of Fame may always elude Maris, the rejuvination of interest in his career may work in his favor to one day get the call to Cooperstown. Ben Shpigel has covered the Mets for The Times since 2005. I have read alot about baseball and the greats of the game. Tyler Kepner has covered the Yankees for The New York Times since 2002. I don't talk to people about baseball. Thanks for reading. According to the record he wore the number 19 for the 1961 season only. Seems about right for the situation. I would think this guy would be in. Dwight Evans.. Should Be In The Hall Of Fame. Not only for HR record setter, but MVP, world series champ, etc. If Kirby Puckett is a first ballot Hall of Famer, Maris deserves the nod from the Veteran's Committee. A very valuable player indeed. Given the number of legitimate reporters covering the race between him and Mantle and the number of fans attending the games, there is no possible way any of it could have been staged. If nothing else, Maris should at least have a spot in the Hall of Fame . Customer Service. Because except for a a couple seasons, he basically was average https://bleacherreport.com/articles/221894-the-king-without-a-crown-should-roger-maris-be-in-the-hall-of-fame. The Indians had a glut of outfielders in their organization and inexplicably ignored the 69 homers Maris hit in three seasons in their system. I don't even think there's a fair slippery slope case because in 60 years nobody without mostly verified allegations has topped him. While fans largely celebrated Mantle, Maris received hate mail and threats from fans who thought he was unworthy of the Great Bambinos record. In 1961, Maris did not homer in his first ten games, but by the end of May he had hit 12. Mazeroski, like Maris, was a.260 career hitter, but hit just 138 home runs in 17 seasons and never finished higher than eighth in the MVP voting. We could all stipulate that anybody who experienced an injury during the grueling season could have done it. Even if you werent as good as the man who played center field next to you. There were over 500 other baseball players during this expansion era and they did not hit 61 home runs. Or that Jose Molina or David Wells knows enough about baseball history to know who should get a plaque? Johnny Vander Meer: Pitched back-to-back no hitters in 1938. Here are my reasons/rebuttals that Maris does not belong in the Hall of Fame. Does he belong in the Hall of Fame? Roger Maris And, just as importantly to me, inducting Maris would be an indirect way to acknowledge that not only did Maris set that record, he holds that record to this day. Reynolds, a standout hurler for the Indians and Yankees from 1942-54, received six votes from the 16-member electorate charged with reviewing the Early Baseball Era ballot. Nobody, it seemed, wanted him to break Babe Ruth's record. Why Hall of Fame 61 on the last day of the season. I stand by what I wrote about Maris: there isnt enough of a career there to merit Hall of Fame election. His 1961 season was the best of his career, and one of the best seasons of all time. He won one Gold Glove, and in 1967 he drove in seven runs in the World Series. Acquired by the Yankees in October 1946, Reynolds flourished in New York, as he was a five-time All-Star and a six-time World Series champion over his eight seasons with the Yanks. Before that, Curry covered the Yankees from 1991-1997. Maris made his Major League debut on April 16, 1957, with the Cleveland Indians. It is possible that any player since steroids were invented cheated.

Tony Douglas Etihad Net Worth, Christine White Married, What Happened To Genshiro Kawamoto, Articles W